Equity Refresh: A Fresh Approach to Employee Compensation

Equity refresh grants are an essential tool for startup founders like you, designed to ensure your team remains motivated and engaged over the long term. As your employees progress in their roles, the initial stock options or Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) that were part of their equity compensation packages begin to vest. This often creates a challenge where they might feel less incentivized once their equity has vested or when their initial stock package feels outdated in comparison to your startup's current valuation.

An equity refresh program steps in as a solution to this problem. It involves offering additional stock or equity-based compensation after the initial grants vest, renewing employees' investment in your company's success. These refreshes are strategically timed to maintain employee engagement, prevent turnover, and encourage a sense of loyalty. By regularly offering equity refreshes, you can recognize the ongoing contributions of your employees and provide a forward-looking incentive to them.

This blog explores different facets of equity refresh programs, including their importance, timing, structure, benefits, challenges, and others. Keep reading to learn more.

What is an equity refresh?

An equity refresh is a strategic compensation tool that helps you retain your key employees by offering them new stock options or equity grants. This strategy is typically used when their initial equity grants are nearing the end of their vesting period.  

Under this method, rather than relying only on salary increases or bonuses, you offer new stock options or grants to the employees, extending their financial stake in the company's future. Regularly refreshing equity stakes keeps employees invested in their roles, driving sustained performance and contributing to a stable, motivated workforce.

Through an equity refresh program, you signal to your team that their contributions are recognized and that you want them to be part of the company's next phase of growth. 

Why are equity refresh programs essential for retention?

Retaining your company's top performers is more challenging than ever in competitive industries. Being a founder, you are not just competing with other startups; you are also up against established companies that can offer lucrative compensation packages. As a result, equity refresh programs are no longer just a nice-to-have for startups; they are becoming must-haves. 

By continuously offering new stock options or frequent equity grants, you can ensure that the employees remain incentivized to stay with your company. This ongoing reward system is crucial in keeping your team engaged and committed.

Equity refresh is particularly important in fast-paced industries where job-hopping is common. Providing fresh equity stakes regularly helps maintain a sense of value and belonging among your employees, making it harder for them to be lured away by competitors. As your company evolves, the roles and contributions of your team members also grow. Refreshing equity grants recognize their ongoing efforts and reaffirm their importance to the company's success.

Implementing an equity refresh program demonstrates a forward-thinking approach to talent retention. It signals to your team that you are invested in their long-term growth and satisfaction. This can boost your employee retention efforts and make your startup more attractive to potential hires.

When should you offer equity refresh grants?

Timing is extremely important when it comes to offering equity refresh grants. Most companies, particularly in the startup space, typically issue these grants after an employee's initial stock options or RSUs are nearing the end of their vesting period, usually around the 3-4-year mark. 

As a founder, you should carefully monitor this timeline. Offering equity refresh grants too late can lead to employee dissatisfaction and increase the risk of turnover. Employees who see their equity nearing full vesting may start exploring opportunities elsewhere, seeking new incentives and fresh stock options. On the other hand, introducing a refresh too early can dilute its impact, as the perceived value may not be as high when the original equity is still in play.

It is important to strike a balance. The ideal time to offer equity refreshes is shortly before their initial equity fully vests. This timing ensures that your employees remain invested in the company's future while also feeling continuously rewarded for their loyalty and contributions. This proactive approach would help you maintain a strongly motivated workforce that is aligned with your company's goals.

Structuring your equity refresh program

Creating an effective equity refresh program involves various important considerations to make sure that it meets your company's goals and helps retain top talent. Here are some suggestions on how to structure it:

• Deciding the amount of equity to offer: Determine the appropriate amount of additional equity to grant based on the employee's role, performance, and tenure. Align the equity offered with your company's growth stage and valuation to maintain fairness and competitiveness.
• Determining vesting schedules: Decide whether to mirror the original vesting period or adopt a different schedule. Commonly, companies use a new four-year vesting period with a one-year cliff to maintain consistency and incentivize long-term commitment.
• Tying grants to performance or tenure: Link the equity refresh grants to specific performance milestones or tenure with the company. This approach ensures that the equity refresh rewards employees who significantly contribute to the company's success and demonstrate loyalty.
• Regular refresh cycles: Establish a systematic refresh cycle, such as annual equity refresh grants, to provide ongoing incentives and keep employees motivated. Regular refreshes help maintain engagement and prevent the risk of turnover as initial grants vest.
• Performance-based refreshes: Consider performance-based refreshes for high achievers to recognize and reward exceptional contributions. This strategy promotes a culture of excellence and encourages employees to go above and beyond in their roles.

The typical size of an equity refresh grant is usually 25% or lower (in some cases 30%) than the initial new hire grant at the same level. This percentage can vary depending on a company's specific compensation philosophy and acceptable dilution levels.

Benefits of equity refresh grants for companies and employees

Equity refresh grants offer numerous benefits for both companies and employees, playing a crucial role in retaining top talent and ensuring continued engagement. 

• Continued financial upside for employees: Equity refreshers provide your employees with ongoing financial incentives, allowing them to benefit from the company's growth beyond their initial equity grant. This ensures that their potential rewards increase as your startup grows.
• Sense of ownership: Equity strengthens employees' sense of ownership, reinforcing their commitment to the company's success. When you make your employees feel like true stakeholders, they are more likely to invest their time and effort into their roles.
• Boosting employee loyalty: Equity refreshes help employers retain high-performing employees who might otherwise consider leaving after their initial stock options have fully vested. By continually offering new equity, you keep employees motivated and loyal.
• Reducing turnover costs: Equity refreshes can significantly mitigate the financial and operational costs of employee turnover, ensuring valuable talent remains with the company longer. This stability is crucial for maintaining consistent growth and minimizing disruptions.
• Retention of key talent during growth phases: Equity refresh programs are especially critical during high-growth periods, where the company needs its best talent to continue executing strategic goals. Keeping key team members engaged ensures that growth initiatives are implemented effectively.
• Avoiding the 'Golden Handcuffs': This refers to the situation where employees leave after their initial options have vested. A well-timed equity refresh program can mitigate this risk by re-engaging employees with new incentives for staying with your company, thus avoiding turnover at critical junctures.

Common pitfalls to avoid in equity refresh programs

Implementing an equity refresh program comes with its own set of challenges. Here are some pitfalls to watch out for:

• Over-dilution of existing shares: Offering too many refresh grants can dilute the overall ownership structure. This reduces the value of existing shareholders' stakes, including those of both employees and founders. It is essential to undertake a balanced approach to avoid diminishing the equity's worth.
• Not offering enough equity: On the flip side, if the refresh grant is too small, it may not be meaningful enough to motivate or retain employees. An insufficient grant can render the program ineffective, failing to achieve its intended purpose of retention.
• Risk of reset fatigue: Employees might come to expect regular refresh grants, leading to 'reset fatigue.' The value of each new grant diminishes in their eyes, turning these rewards into perceived entitlements rather than special incentives.
• Balancing motivation and dilution: Balancing the equity refresh program is essential to provide enough incentives to motivate employees while maintaining equity value for shareholders. Finding this equilibrium ensures the program's effectiveness without over-diluting shares.
• Lack of transparency and communication: Failing to communicate the employee benefits and rationale behind this equity program clearly can lead to misunderstandings or dissatisfaction among employees. Ensure transparency and effective communication to align expectations and foster trust.

Legal and tax considerations for equity refresh

Implementing an equity refresh program requires careful attention to legal and tax considerations to ensure compliance and avoid potential pitfalls.

Legal considerations

In the US, companies must comply with federal securities laws, such as the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and the Securities Act of 1933. These laws regulate the issuance of stock and equity grants, requiring proper documentation and disclosure to employees. 

Any stock options or RSUs issued through an equity refresh must adhere to the regulatory framework defined by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Depending on the size of your company and the nature of the grants, you may need to register the stock options or file for exemptions.

State-specific securities laws may also apply, and you must ensure compliance with these regulations as well. Experts at Qapita can help you navigate these requirements and ensure that all equity refresh grants are issued in accordance with applicable laws.

Tax implications for employees

Equity refresh grants have specific tax implications based on the type of equity received. For refreshed stock options or RSUs, the gap between the grant price and Fair Market Value (FMV) at vesting or exercise is taxed as ordinary income. However, holding the shares for a longer period can qualify the employees for lower long-term capital gains tax rates. 

Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) may receive favorable tax treatment if held for at least two years after the grant and one year after exercise. On the other hand, Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs) are taxed as ordinary income when exercised.

Tax implications for companies

From a company's perspective, offering equity refresh grants comes with its own set of tax obligations. You may be eligible for a corporate tax deduction when employees exercise their stock options or when their RSUs vest. However, this deduction will depend on the timing and the type of equity being offered. Your company must also comply with payroll tax obligations for the ordinary income employees receive from stock options. This will help ensure that proper withholding and reporting are in place.

Conclusion

As a startup founder, incorporating equity refreshes into your company's compensation philosophy is essential, especially in competitive markets where retaining key talent is critical. By doing so, you create a culture of loyalty and engagement, positioning your company for sustainable growth.

At Qapita, we understand the complexities of equity management, which is why our platform is designed to help you streamline your processes, from cap table management to ESOPs and liquidity programs. Our goal is to simplify equity workflows and provide valuable tools that ensure compliance and efficiency. Whether you are looking to manage your ownership records or create a structured equity compensation review process, our experts are here to help you every step of the way.

Our equity management platform is rated as #1 by G2 and is trusted by over 2,000 rapidly growing companies worldwide. Let us assist you in optimizing your equity refresh program and enhancing your employee experience. Contact our team to learn more. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How do you allocate equity to employees?

To allocate equity to employees, consider seniority, tenure, and individual contributions. Establish a vesting schedule over four years with a one-year cliff to ensure long-term commitment. Use an ESOP calculator for precise equity distribution. Regularly review and adjust allocations to reflect role changes and performance. Ensure the equity refresh process is transparent and fair to uphold employee trust and morale.

Why do companies offer equity refreshes?

Companies offer equity refreshes to retain top talent, boost employee morale, and maintain long-term commitment. As initial equity grants vest, refresh grants provide continued financial incentives, aligning employees with the company's success. This approach helps reduce turnover, fosters a sense of ownership, and keeps employees engaged and motivated. 

Who is eligible for an equity refresh?

Typically, employees who have been with the company for a significant period and have made substantial contributions to its success are eligible for an equity refresh.

‍